Reformation Cary High Rise Jeans Review: The Jeans I Would Buy Again Immediately

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you.

I was so excited to find this style because I felt like I’d been looking for the right colour and cut for the longest time. I wanted something high waisted, relaxed through the leg and a little bit slouchy, but not so oversized that it completely overwhelmed me. The Cary jeans felt like exactly that.

I bought my first pair in Ondine after seeing someone wearing the low rise version in an Aritzia changing room. I liked them so much that I had to ask her what jeans she was wearing. I went home to order them, saw there was a high rise version and, because I have wider hips and almost always feel more comfortable in a higher waist, decided to go for those instead.

Then came the impatient wait for them to arrive.

I remember feeling like I had been waiting forever for them to arrive, mostly because I was already so convinced they were going to be the jeans I’d been looking for. Thankfully, they did not disappoint.

I wear them constantly. Day to day, for dinners, drinks, conferences, summer evenings, autumn, winter. They have somehow become the jeans I reach for when I don’t know what else to wear, but also the jeans I reach for when I actually want to feel properly dressed.

I now own them in Di Latte too, so this probably goes without saying but I love the jeans!

For reference, I’m 5’1, have a 25-inch waist and fuller hips, and I wear a size 26. I sized for my hips and had the waist taken in and the length shortened by my tailor, but this is very normal for me with trousers and jeans.

Reformation Cary High Rise Jeans in Ondie styled with baby tee and coach chelsea bag

My Reformation Cary High Rise Jeans review at a glance

Rating: 5/5
Size: 26
My height: 5’1
My waist: 25 inches
Fit: Genuinely high rise with a relaxed, slouchy wide leg
Stretch: More rigid than stretchy
Would I buy them again? Immediately. I already bought another colour.
Best for: Anyone who loves a wider jean but still wants something flattering, wearable and easy to style.

How do the Reformation Cary High Rise Jeans fit?

The fit is basically the entire reason I love them. They are genuinely high rise on me, which I much prefer with my proportions, and then they fall into this really gorgeous vintage slouch through the leg.

The word slouch is probably more accurate because I don’t think these are just a standard wide leg jean. They have volume, but they don’t feel huge. They are relaxed without looking sloppy, and wide without swallowing me, which at 5’1 is obviously something I’m very aware of.

I think that balance is what makes them so easy to wear. They have enough shape to make an outfit feel interesting, but they don’t require you to completely rethink the rest of your wardrobe.

They also don’t feel like one of those jeans that looks very current for six months and then suddenly feels incredibly specific to a moment.

They have a slightly vintage feel, but still look modern.

Reformation Cary sizing

I wear a 26. My waist is around 25 inches, but I have fuller hips, so I tend to size for my hips and deal with the waist afterwards. That’s what I did here. I had the waist taken in and the length shortened by my tailor.

I wouldn’t personally call that a downside because I have this issue with a lot of trousers, but if you have a similar waist-to-hip difference, it’s worth knowing.

The jeans fit comfortably over my hips and don’t feel restrictive when I sit down, which is always one of my main concerns with denim.

Are the Reformation Cary jeans good for petites?

Yes, but I would absolutely expect to hem them if you’re around my height. I’m 5’1 and had mine shortened. I actually think wide jeans can look great on a petite frame, but the length has to be right. If there’s too much fabric pooling at the bottom, the whole proportion starts to feel heavier. Once mine were altered, I thought they were incredibly flattering. The high waist helps, but I also think the leg falls in a way that feels long rather than bulky.

So I wouldn’t rule these out just because you’re petite. I would just factor alterations into the cost.

Are the Reformation Cary jeans stretchy?

Not really. I would describe the denim as more rigid and structured, but not stiff. And because the jean itself is so relaxed through the leg, I don’t think you miss the stretch. They are extremely comfortable. I can wear them all day without thinking about them, and they don’t have that annoying thing some rigid jeans do where you’re suddenly desperate to get them off after dinner.

They also hold their shape really well. Mine haven’t noticeably bagged at the knees, and I haven’t found that they loosen dramatically after a few hours of wear.

Do they soften over time?

Not massively, at least not in a way I’ve noticed. But I also don’t think they ever had that really stiff, new-denim feeling in the first place. They’ve held up well through washing and still have the same structure I liked when I first bought them. The denim feels substantial, but not uncomfortable, which is probably the best combination for a pair of jeans you want to wear regularly.

Why I keep reaching for them

This is probably the biggest compliment I can give them: they make very normal clothes look better.

A baby tee and jeans is not exactly a groundbreaking outfit. But with the Cary, the shape of the jean is doing enough that the outfit still feels thought about. That is what I mean when I say these are an everything jean for me. I don’t need to build some complicated look around them. They work with the clothes I already own, but they make those clothes look better. And I think that is why I’ve never really gotten bored of them.

They are also one of the few pairs of jeans I own that can make me feel put together without making me feel overdressed. I can wear them with a very simple top and flats, or add a heel and something more feminine for dinner, and both outfits feel like me.

How I style the Reformation Cary High Rise Jeans

I wear these in so many different ways, but I definitely prefer them with a more delicate shoe. The jeans already have quite a lot of volume, so I like the contrast of something slimmer or more refined underneath.

Day to day

Reformation Cary High Rise Jeans styled casually

Autumn and winter

I love them with a fitted tee, pointed heeled boots and my Aritzia wool coat. The pointed boot works particularly well because it gives you some shape underneath the wider leg.

Sometimes on cooler evenings in spring or fall, I’ll throw my wool coat over them but pair with a flip flop. I personally wouldn’t reach for a chunky trainer with them. I think the jeans already have enough visual weight, so adding another heavy shape at the bottom can make the whole thing feel too bulky. A daintier trainer could work, though.

And I actually think they could look very good with a wedge too.

Reformation Cary High Rise Jeans outfit inspo

Dinner

For dinner, I love them with something that feels a bit more feminine on top. One of my favorite looks is a red off-the-shoulder top, gold jewelry and heeled boots is exactly the kind of outfit I mean.

The jeans stop it from feeling too dressed up, but the top and shoes make it feel intentional.

Reformation Cary High Rise Jeans styled for dinner

Drinks

A halter neck top or vest with a heel. Again, I’d probably go for a heeled boot or a flip-flop style heel rather than anything chunky. The jeans make the outfit feel a little more relaxed, which I like. They stop a going-out top from feeling too obvious.

Reformation Cary High Rise Jeans styled for drinks

Summer

I still wear my Ondine pair in summer, especially at night. Baby tee, flip-flops, jeans. Done. I think this is also part of why I’ve gotten so much wear out of them. They don’t feel tied to one season.

Reformation Cary High Rise Jeans styled with white baby tee

What shoes look best with the Cary jeans?

For me:

  • Pointed heeled boots
  • Ballet flats
  • Flip-flops
  • Flip-flop heels
  • Delicate sandals
  • Slim trainers
  • Wedges

The only thing I personally wouldn’t rush to style them with is a very chunky trainer.

Not because it can’t work, but because I prefer the contrast of the slouchier jean with something more delicate underneath.

What don’t I like about them?

This is difficult because I genuinely haven’t found much. They are a 5/5 jean for me. The length is obviously something to think about if you’re petite, and if you have a smaller waist with fuller hips, you may also need the waist altered. But both of those things are so standard for me that I don’t really hold them against the jean.

The only other reason I wouldn’t recommend them is if you simply don’t feel like yourself in a wider, slouchier silhouette. There’s no point forcing yourself into a shape because it’s popular. But if this is already the kind of jean you gravitate towards, I think the Cary is incredibly good.

Are the Reformation Cary High Rise Jeans worth $178?

For me, yes. Completely. I think the easiest way to tell whether something was actually worth the money is how much you reach for it once the excitement of buying it has worn off. I still reach for these constantly. And more importantly, I bought them again in another color.

That is a much stronger endorsement to me than saying I loved them the first week I owned them. I bought Ondine first, loved the fit so much that I bought Di Latte, and if I ever wear my Ondine pair into the ground, I will buy them again.

Final verdict

Would I buy the Reformation Cary High Rise Jeans again? Immediately. I’ve tried and tested enough jeans to know when something is going to become a genuine wardrobe staple, and these have absolutely earned that status for me. They are flattering, comfortable, incredibly easy to style and somehow manage to feel relaxed without ever feeling sloppy.

Most importantly, they are the kind of jeans I was excited to receive, excited to wear and still excited to put on now. I wear them too often, I’ve bought them twice, and I would replace them if I had to.

5/5.

7edfe486 c8ee 4530 86e7 51111725d246

Nicole

Editor of Becoming Uncultured

Nicole has spent seven years working across fashion, beauty and home, partnering with brands across the luxury and premium markets. After years spent researching brands and products and testing hundreds of products herself, she created Becoming Uncultured to help women make more considered purchases through recommendations grounded in both industry experience and real world use.

Leave a Comment