
Welcome to the first ever Uncultured Edit, or should I say Nicole’s little internet diary, where I get to talk about, well, whatever I want, because it’s my corner of the internet.
When I launched Becoming Uncultured, I had this vision of creating a community and connecting with people who feel like they’re missing a little bit of the passion, discovery and thought-provoking conversation that used to come with shopping. And while The Uncultured Edit will, for now, be a monthly collection of my thoughts on absolutely anything, I thought I’d start by sharing a little more about what inspired Becoming Uncultured in the first place.
Some of my friends, who have been great supporters of Becoming Uncultured, will tell you that I love talking about shopping and marketing. I’m also usually the first person to send the group chat a text asking what everybody is wearing tonight. But for someone who loves shopping as much as I do, the way shopping culture is evolving online is giving me the major ick.
I work in marketing, so I’m all too familiar with the acronym LTV. For anybody who isn’t, it stands for lifetime value, a metric brands use to understand how much revenue a customer generates over their relationship with a business. How often you shop, how much you spend and how long you stick around.
And I know brands are taking the idea of LTV to a whole other level. It’s no longer just about getting us to spend more on their products. They’re finding ways to make money from our attention, too. Getting offered a streaming service subscription while using Uber seems a little weird, right? That’s because it is. Don’t even get me started on pausing a television show only to be met with an ad. Every corner we turn, it’s ad, ad, ad, and it all feels so hollow.
Even the ways brands connect with us are becoming increasingly calculated. You shop online, there’s a store near you, and suddenly there’s an email inviting you to pop in and say hello. It reads as though somebody has personally thought to invite you, when really it’s another automated attempt to get you back through the door. And look, I work in marketing. I know why brands do these things. But sometimes the sheer volume of it all is exhausting.
When I landed back home at the airport recently, Lyft sent me a notification welcoming me home and suggesting I book a ride. I actually booked an Uber instead because I was so against being treated like some ultra-optimization project in that moment. I know Uber is no better, but I was feeling rebellious.
I’m not against personalization. I actually quite like being introduced to things that suit my taste. But I feel like we’re getting to a point where it’s all becoming a little too much? It’s almost as though every interaction needs to be analyzed, every interest needs to lead to something and every opportunity to get us to spend another dollar needs to be taken.
It’s hard to deny that we’re heading toward a world where we’ll each have our own little AI shopping assistant, learning everything about our tastes, predicting what we’ll want next and practically doing the shopping for us. Convenient? Sure. But I do wonder what happens to the fun of discovering things for ourselves.
Amazon, for example, now has a feature called Amazon Interests, which uses AI to find and recommend products based on your interests. You can even tell it what you’re interested in so it can keep looking for things you might like. Ironically, despite Amazon’s best efforts to optimize our lives and predict what we’ll want next, some of the interests it has identified for me are guitar accessories and books. Two things I’ve been spending more time with precisely to get myself away from this advertising and algorithm abyss we seem to be sinking deeper and deeper into.
And there’s something else about shopping lately that I can’t quite shake. The sameness of it all. TikTok is the same products being recommended again and again. Amazon is full of the same finds, and when something arrives, it’s in another Amazon box. I know it’s only packaging, but I actually love receiving a parcel that feels like it belongs to the brand I bought it from. Something that gives you a little sense of their personality or vision. It doesn’t need to be extravagant or wasteful. It’s just that another brown Amazon box is, well, a little boring.
I actually very rarely shop on Amazon, perhaps four times a year when convenience wins out. I try my best to shop directly with brands or at least through retailers that feel like they have a little more substance and personality. I’m not even particularly jaded toward somewhere like Sephora. I still enjoy wandering around, looking at products and discovering brands I hadn’t necessarily gone in to find.
I’ve been burned by these quick little shopping moments that seem to be everywhere. I recently got served an ad for a knitted wool skirt that I absolutely loved. I spent $200 on her and was so excited when she arrived. Except she was completely see-through. I felt disappointed. Not only had the ad failed to mention that I’d need an underskirt, but the creative itself gave absolutely no indication that it was sheer.
And look, I get it. The brand wants to sell me the skirt, and I do love it. But surely for $200 we can have a little more conversation about the practicality of the thing? I ended up starting a conversation on Reddit because I wanted to figure out how to make it work. And ironically, after all that clever targeting, it was a conversation with actual people that helped me find a solution.
I’m not expecting anybody to anticipate every possible problem, but I do think there’s something missing when we’re so good at selling people things and not particularly interested in talking about what they’re actually like to own.

I was shopping with my friend the other day, and she simply wanted a particular top in plain black. I couldn’t believe how many stores were selling literally the exact same top. Not something similar, the exact same top, just in different colors and patterns. Baby pink stripes in one store, navy in another. I honestly wondered if they’d all come from the same factory and just changed the labels. It was insane.
Unsurprisingly, I was getting the most joy out of walking around designer, vintage and resale stores. I’m usually very considered when it comes to spending money, but I got so caught up in the excitement of discovering this preloved Gucci bag with the most gorgeous pop of green that I almost impulsively spent $1,250 on it. Thankfully, I stopped myself and thought, wait, do I actually love the all over Gucci branding? As it turns out, not quite enough to spend $1,250.
But I loved that moment. The spontaneity of it. Probably 90% of the things I came across weren’t for me, and I loved that too. There was something almost rebellious about being surrounded by things I didn’t particularly want. Nobody had decided what I was supposed to like before I walked in. I was just looking around, finding things for myself, and feeling genuinely excited about shopping again.

It’s not as though following trends is anything new. We’ve always been influenced by magazines, celebrities, advertising and each other. But I do wonder whether the speed of it all, and how precisely we’re now being targeted, is taking some of the fun out of figuring out what we actually like. All this personalization and optimization is starting to feel a little overwhelming, and I’m finding myself wanting some distance from it.
And listen, I know I’ve chosen to spend my time on these platforms and engage with all of it. I’m very aware of that. But I’ve reached a point where I’m starting to question just how much space I want to give it in my life.
I did something that I thought was a little radical this morning. I woke up and stopped myself mid-routine from picking up my phone. I genuinely couldn’t remember the last time I’d done that, which is a little embarrassing. Ten years? Maybe more? And as I sat there thinking about it, my brain went, okay, get your phone. And I just said no.
So I sat with my thoughts for a few more minutes, got out of bed, stretched and looked around my room. And I had this moment of clarity where I thought, actually, I want to do my morning routine without even knowing what’s on my phone. I got ready for the day and eventually made my way downstairs with my phone and laptop, still without checking either. I sat at down while my coffee brewed, and I can’t tell you how many times I had to resist the urge to pick up my phone. When I finally did, I realized just how underwhelming the feeling was. And I felt really good about that.
I’ve been drastically overhauling my habits lately. Working on Becoming Uncultured has given me a creative outlet that helps me feel fulfilled, I’ve been watching way more TV shows and movies, reading more, and trying to spend a little more time away from my phone.
Look, I don’t think the answer is to stop shopping, abandon technology or pretend I’m suddenly above any of it. I still want to shop. I just want to feel like I’m curating my own world rather than the same world everybody else seems to be curating. And sometimes I’d be lost without technology. Not being able to order sushi would definitely be a downgrade in my world.
I think I’m just excited to go on my own little journey of discovery, whatever that might look like. I want a little more human mess and contradiction in my world, and I don’t particularly want everything I do, like or think to make perfect sense to an algorithm.
And well, here we are. I suppose it’s all these little moments that have led me here, to Becoming Uncultured, and to wanting to be a little more curious about what I choose to bring into my world.
I don’t promise you’ll love everything I love, and that’s okay. That’s actually what I want.
Until next month,
Nicole x